It seems like a lot of people choose to use Evernote instead of One Note for organizing/compiling their research. I too had fallen into this mindset. Then one day while I was adding some photos to a note I got a message that made me completely change my mind:
I had gone over the size limit of 25 MB for my note. Now, I like to include all of my organized information for a person in one document. If I didn't then my files would very quickly become a mess. Once I started looking into alternatives to Evernote I very quickly made my decision to switch to One Note. Its important note here that I am a windows user. One Note lacks a lot of functional support for other operating systems since it is made by windows. However, for all you Windows Users out there, this is why you should switch to One Note for all your Genealogy related needs.
#1: Price
This is the real deal breaker in my opinion. Evernote offers 4 tiers:
- Basic, which is free
- Plus, which costs $34.99 per year
- Premium, which costs $69.99 per year
- Business. which costs $120 per year.
One Note in comparison has only one tier:
- One Note, which is free
Need I even say more?
#2: Storage
Now I know what you are thinking; "If One Note is free then doesn't it have less features than the paid versions of Evernote?" The answer is largely no, as you will see in this section and the sections that follow it. The difference in storage was the catalyst for my decision to switch to One Note. First lets take a look at the amount of storage you are allotted for each tier in Evernote:
- Basic: 60 MB in monthly note uploads and 25 MB for a single note
- Plus: 1 GB in monthly note uploads and 50 MB for a single note
- Premium: 10 GB in monthly note uploads and 200 MB for a single note
- Business: 10 GB in monthly personal note uploads, 2 GB per user in monthly business uploads, and 200 MB for a single note
Now to compare that with One Note: Unlimited monthly uploads and Unlimited note size. Really all that limits the amount of data you put into one note is how much your computer can store.
#3 Features
So, not that we've got Price and Storage covered lets take a look at what each of the apps actually offers. Now right off the bat I will say this: Evernote's web clipper is far better than One Note's. It has more options for what parts of a web page you can save and an advanced annotation tool. However, if this is as unimportant to you as it is to me then I guarantee One Note's capabilities will be far more appealing to you than Evernote's.Here are the major differences in features:
Interface
This is Evernote's interface. It consists of 3 main columns and 2 rows of options at the top. In my opinion it is cluttered. It has too many options in a single space that make it slower to get to where you need.
As a comparison here is One Note's interface. You can see it has all the basic tools you need on one screen and cuts the unnecessary things. There is an expandable menu in the top left hand corner that contains what you need to easily search and organize your notes. Its much cleaner with fewer distractions than Evernote, which translates to greater productivity and faster work speeds.
Collaboration
One unique feature in One Note is the ability to easily collaborate and share your documents with others. This is available in Evernote, but only in the paid versions. This feature is incredibly useful for working with other researchers. For instance, have a to do list for a shared tree? Just make one in One Note by inserting checkboxes and share it with your fellow researcher! If they complete a task they can check the box and both of you will see that it has been complete. They can even add their own research or notes into your documents, or annotate your theories with proof that confirms or rejects them. The possibilities are endless!
Full control over Layout
Evernote has an amazing feature where you can type anywhere on the page. Just click and type and it will go where you want it to hassle free, you can even move elements of your note sheet around later. If you have a picture, for instance, you can add a caption or add text on top of the image with just a single simple click.
File Attachments
In One Note you can attach any type of file you want to your note. Sound, Video, Pictures, PDFs, you name it you can attach it. Combine this with the share function and you can upload gedcoms and share them with your fellow collaborators so they can easily download them. You could also share audio interviews with each other or just use your notes as a place to store the audio you've collected for yourself.OCR Tools
OCR is short for Optical character recognition. It allows a machine to read the words within an image. Both Evernote and One Note have OCR, but One Note is the only one that lets you actually copy the text inside the image so you can paste it elsewhere. OCR isn't always completely accurate, but sometimes it means the difference between transcribing thousands of words by hand and using a simple copy paste.
Drawing Tools
One Note has a large amount of drawing tools, many of which are unavailable in Evernote. It has Pen tools with a much larger width variance than the ones offered by Evernote and more shapes you can use for annotating. It's lasso select tool also makes selecting and moving the annotations you draw easy.
How to Make the Switch
Luckily its pretty easy to transfer your Evernotes to One Notes. You'll find an importer tool here.
I personally got very good results using the tool. It kept all of my formatting perfectly and looks like I made it naive in One Note. Also, I would recommend downloading the 2013 version of OneNote, even if you have windows 10. it has more features and better exporting options. You can download the 2013 version here.
Is One Note truly better for genealogy than Evernote? Let me know in the comments what you think!
Hi Renee. I removed my earlier comment because I missed some typos.
ReplyDeleteMaybe I am missing something or need to look at One Note again. Or, maybe it’s just the usual, what works for one person doesn’t always work for another. Perhaps you can help me out with a question about the notebook structure in One Note.
I am a long time Evernote user. I have the Premium version. I have tried One Note several times because I think we should explore all our options. However, the one thing isn't covered in your post, is the thing I have trouble with. The organization aspect of One Note. I just can’t seem to figure out the whole notebook structure vs the structure in Evernote. And what about tags? I use them daily to find what I want. I am not one who uses EN to store documents, that’s why I have a digital filing system on my computer. What I do use it for is organizing for genealogy trips, storing website links, organizing DNA matches, keeping copies of all my blog posts, taking notes during seminars and conferences, keeping track of correspondence with cousins, storing information about surnames and places and emailing things to myself for storage in the proper notebook. I always want to use the most efficient tools available and am open to new ideas.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
It may very well be that what works for me may not work for you, but I think that maybe I’ll be able to clear some things up regardless ð
DeleteWhile One Note does have tags, the difference is they are object tags as opposed to full page tags. Theoretically you could just tag the page header though to take care of that. What I mean by object tags is you can select a tag for a specific paragraph or image, multimedia item, etc. You can make these tags change the formatting of the object they are applied to if you want. You can also find all objects that use a certain tag. You can also tie tags to keystrokes. When tags are applied, you can also choose to use an icon to show on the page. Here is an example of how these tags can be used: https://i.imgur.com/4CChvez.png . I use them to mark which records of suspected relatives I have added to my program and which I have not. At least for how I use them, they are a bit more useful than Evernote’s tags. I think I will start writing a follow up post on this addressing organization specifically.
It sounds though like you are a much more heavy duty user than I am. I just use word to do a lot of the things you described and manage files and notes within my computer's filesystem. My notes in One Note tend to be more temporary and are for following hunches for the most part.
Delete